top of page

Subject-To vs. Assumable Loans. What’s the Difference and Which Is Better?

In today’s high-interest rate environment, savvy buyers and investors are looking for creative ways to finance real estate without paying 7%+ on a new mortgage. Two powerful options are Subject-To financing and Assumable Loans—but they’re often misunderstood or confused with each other.
At The Hegney Group, we specialize in creative deal structuring across San Luis Obispo County, helping sellers, buyers, and investors take advantage of existing low-interest loans. In this post, we’ll break down Subject-To vs. Assumable Loans—the differences, pros, cons, and when each strategy makes the most sense.

Subject-To vs. Assumable Loans. What’s the Difference and Which Is Better?

What Is a Subject-To Deal?

A Subject-To real estate deal means the buyer purchases a property subject to the existing mortgage. The loan stays in the seller’s name, but the buyer takes over the payments and takes legal title to the property.

Key Points:

  • The buyer does not assume the loan officially

  • The lender is usually not notified

  • The seller’s loan remains active (and on their credit report)

  • The buyer gains ownership, equity, and control of the asset

This strategy is most common in off-market or distressed situations, especially when sellers are behind on payments or want to avoid foreclosure.


What Is an Assumable Loan?

An Assumable Loan is a mortgage that can be formally transferred to a new buyer with the lender’s approval. The buyer takes over the original loan terms—interest rate, balance, and amortization schedule.

Most common with:

  • VA Loans

  • FHA Loans

  • Some USDA Loans

Key Differences from Subject-To:

  • The loan is transferred legally and formally

  • The buyer must qualify with the lender

  • The seller is released from liability

  • The lender is fully involved in the process

When Should You Use a Subject-To Deal?

Subject-To is ideal when:

  • The seller is behind on payments or facing foreclosure

  • The property won’t qualify for traditional financing

  • The buyer wants to avoid lender red tape

  • You’re structuring a creative investment deal (like seller financing or renovations)

Example:
CJ Hegney helped a seller in Paso Robles avoid foreclosure by purchasing Subject-To and catching up on back payments. The 4% interest loan was left in place—saving the buyer thousands per year compared to new financing.


When Should You Use an Assumable Loan?

An Assumable Loan is better when:

  • The loan is a VA, FHA, or USDA product

  • The buyer wants a clean transfer and lender blessing

  • The seller insists on being released from the loan

  • The buyer can qualify and doesn’t mind a slower process

Example:
A home in Arroyo Grande with a 3.25% VA loan was assumed by a new buyer, avoiding current 7% rates. The buyer went through underwriting and the seller was fully released from all liability.


Which Is Better?

It depends on your situation.

Use Subject-To if:

  • You’re buying off-market

  • The seller is motivated or distressed

  • You want a fast, flexible, and creative close

  • You’re OK taking on the loan without lender involvement

Use an Assumable Loan if:

  • The loan is assumable (VA/FHA/USDA)

  • You want full legal transfer and seller release

  • You can qualify with the lender

  • You're buying a home on-market and want low fixed-rate terms

How CJ Hegney Helps Structure These Deals

At The Hegney Group, we specialize in:

  • Subject-To purchases

  • Assumable loan negotiations

  • Seller financing combinations

  • Creative structuring with legal and escrow support

We’ve helped clients all across San Luis Obispo County, including Grover Beach, Paso Robles, and Morro Bay, turn low-interest mortgages into major opportunities.


Want Help Structuring Your Deal?

Whether you're a:

  • Seller stuck with payments

  • Buyer priced out by today’s interest rates

  • Investor looking for creative financing

CJ Hegney can help you navigate Subject-To deals and Assumable Loans the right way—with legal compliance, full disclosures, and smart risk mitigation.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
bottom of page